Published: February 14, 2020 |

[Click image to enlarge]

A federal judge has overturned environmental permits for the proposed Rosemont Copper Mine, saying the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service failed to consider the mine’s impact on several endangered species in the Santa Rita Mountains.

It’s just the latest setback for the planned open-pit mine, whose owners said Monday’s ruling “does not come as a surprise in light of the court’s previous decisions.” But Hudbay Minerals Inc. also said it is not giving up on the planned open-pit mine in the Coronado National Forest.

“While we respect the court’s authority to remand the analysis and findings back to the agencies for further review, Hudbay believes this is unnecessary and remains committed to advancing the project which will benefit the region as a critical economic and employment driver,” the company’s statement said.

The suit is just one of three pending against the mine, which Hudbay notes has already been subject to 11 years of “careful review and study by 17 cooperating agencies.”

The project calls for a mine 3,000 feet deep and 6,000 feet wide that one supporter said could be one of the largest copper mines in the U.S. over its 20 to 25 years lifespan. Construction of the mine would cost $1.9 billion and directly employ about 2,500 workers, the company said, while mine operations would employ about 500 workers who would earn, on average, more than twice the Pima County median income.

The mine was set to begin operations last fall, after the U.S. Forest Service gave its final OK. That approval relied on a Fish and Wildlife Service determination that the project would not jeopardize any threatened or endangered species in the area and that “none of the critical habitats were likely to be destroyed or adversely affected by the Rosemont Mine.”

Opponents challenged that claim in court, and Soto halted work on the mine on July 31 – one day before operations were set to begin. A separate suit by the Tohono O’odham, Pascua Yaqui and Hopi tribes claimed that the approval by the Forest Service not only endangered the environment but would block their access to cultural sites in the Santa Rita mountain.

Monday’s ruling was the follow-up to that injunction. Soto said Fish and Wildlife used the wrong standard when determining the mine’s damage to jaguar habitat, failed to identify the “‘tipping’ point” for species such as the Northern Mexican gartersnake, and set improper standards for “incidental take” of seven threatened or endangered species.

Soto rejected opponents’ claims that Fish and Wildlife failed to consider “toxic heavy metal contaminants” from the mine and “cumulative impacts of groundwater drawdown” on wells in the area. He sent the case back to Fish and Wildlife for more review.

Roger Featherstone, director of the Arizona Mining Reform Coalition, said Soto’s ruling points out what environmental advocates have been saying all along – “it’s just too sensitive of an area to allow this kind of development” and “just not worth the risk.”

Rep. Paul Gosar, R-Prescott, called Monday’s decision “yet another disastrous ruling from a partisan Obama-appointed judge.”

“The Rosemont Mine would be the third-largest copper mine in the United States, an industry critical to Arizona’s economy and modern life,” Gosar said in a statement.

“Judge Soto’s ruling undermines the scientifically based decision of the Forest Service, at the behest of serial litigants from radical environmental groups,” he added.

Source: Arizona Daily Sun

To stop by Hudbay’s website, CLICK HERE

Be in-the-know when you’re on-the-go!